Reviewer: Date



Pobieranie 20.92 Kb.
Data07.05.2016
Rozmiar20.92 Kb.
Reviewer: Date ……………………....

.......................................................................................................................................................

Scientific degree, full name

Employment address:

……………………………………………………………………………………………..……

Personal data of the Reviewer are not disclosed to the paper authors.


REVIEWER OPINION ON THE ARTICLE / MONOGRAPH*) cancel if unnecessary
entitled:

…………………………………………………………………………………………………...…………………………………………………………………………………………………...



intended for publication in the journal Proceedings of Electrotechnical Institute (Prace Instytutu Elektrotechniki).






No




Yes






Is the subject matter relevant to the scope of the journal Proceedings of Electrotechnical Institute?










  1. 2

Does the manuscript describe the original work?













Is the topic of the manuscript up to date?













Does/Do the author(s) demonstrate clearly what has been done and why it was worthwhile to be taken up?












Is the title of the manuscript consistent with the contents?










Is the manuscript organised correctly?










Is the used terminology correct and consistent with the obligatory standards?












Are the references adequate?










Is the illustrative material chosen correctly?










The quality of the contained information:















Very good


















Good


















Moderate






Poor (The problem is obvious for specialists)



Recommendation:






Accept






Accept subject to minor revisions (without re-reviewing)






Accept subject to major revisions (with re-reviewing)






Reject

I declare that I do not know any reasons which could affect the objectivity of my review


Signature
……….…………

Detailed comments please place at a separate page


©absta.pl 2016
wyślij wiadomość

    Strona główna